Don't think this is how you repair a laptop

Back in November of last year, I noted that my laptop which was in service for a month, was finally returned back to me, and was as good as new! However, in late January, the laptop locked up, and would not boot anymore. So, it went back in for service, again under extended warranty. From what they told me, the motherboard in the laptop had died, and it needed replacing, but the part was on back order and would take some time to get shipped in. They kept me up to date with the latest on the status of the repair and waiting for the part, which was good, but was often the same thing, "Waiting on the part".

However, on Thursday I got a call in the morning to say that my laptop repairs had been completed and was ready for collection. On speaking to the person calling me, I confirmed with him that the Motherboard was the reason for the problem. I then discussed with him, my disappointment that the laptop had to be serviced again, for a problem that was supposedly fixed last time the laptop was in for service. He didn't seem to care, so I switched questions and asked if they were open on the Weekend. He said they were not, but could organise a Courier to deliver it for me.

It was at this stage I was hesitant, because I could just see them saying they would courier it, but only for $100, at my expense. So i asked the obvious question, "at my expense?". He assured me that it would not be. Great, I thought. About time they took some responsibility for their faulty repair, even if it was just delivery.

Today, the laptop arrived by courier, and I booted it up tonight, expeciting to be able to start reinstalling Linux back onto it.

But this is where the story goes sour..

I noticed as i was getting it out of the box they had shipped it back in, that the cdrom drive (which is slot loading), had some of the plastic facia coming away:

You can see just how much it was coming off in this shot and a side on photo of the same thing

On seeing this, I was quite annoyed, because it seemed that they had damaged the laptop during fixing it. For now I figured, I would check to make it booted, before sending it back to get that replaced^. I was relieved when the computer started to boot, as they definately had fixed the problem. And this is where the relief finishes and ends for tonight.

The screen then came alive and I was greeted by the Acer bios prompt.

[HTML_REMOVED]

More photos of the screen

And then I became annoyed again, because it looks like the laptop that was supposedly fixed ... was not!

So now, on Monday, another call to the good old Extended Warranty place to tell them what has happened, and then to the repair (Highpoint) on Wednesday to show my disaproval and get it fixed.

Wonder if I can get it replaced for a newer model this time.. atleast that way I can almost be sure they haven't broke it .. yet.

Published: 7 March 2008 # — Tags: laptop

Houston, the laptop has landed

As can be noted by the title, my Laptop is now safely at home again, which is the good news.

The bad news is:

  1. I had to ring them today to find out the status, only to find out that it was "ready since last week"
  2. When i went to collect it, I was told I had to paid the unpaid invoice - Which should've been paid by the Underwriters. In the end, after I had to stand there and phone the underwriters, It came down to it was a stuff up by Highpoint, who had not invoiced the underwriters to pay. All they had sent was the quote, which was approved, but no formal invoice.
  3. The above took me 45 minutes! Too damn long. Atleast I made them use their own phone and call me a cab. It's their fault.

Good news:

  1. Laptop is back
  2. Battery has been replaced (tho I haven't powered on to check this yet)
  3. the fan and screen replaced.

If everything works fine, hopefully this is the last you hear from me on this topic :)

Published: 19 November 2007 # — Tags: laptop

Laptop Update and stuff

It's been a month since the original post, and my laptop is still not ready for me to collect it!

They had to get in a part (the mainboard), so they could repair it.. but seems it is taken too long, so they have decided to just attempt to repair it. Thankfully all this labour is on their own time .. doesn't cost me a cent... I just want it back!

Meanwhile, I have ordered a bluetooth GPS Receiver so that I can play around with that on my phone. Fun times definitely to come!

Published: 17 November 2007 # — Tags: laptop

Extended Worries

At the beginning of 2006, I purchased a Acer Aspire 1694, and an extended warranty for 2 years, thru Dick Smith Electronics, which is handled by Prestige Protection.

I had to put in a claim once before, within a few months of owning the laptop, about a faulty fan, which was rectified in no time, as it was under the manufacturers warranty. This was repaired by their approved repairer, Highpoint[HTML_REMOVED]. At the end of it all, I was impressed with the turn around and service, to fix a small problem.

Now of late, the fun has started to have the same symptoms as before (I'm guessed that the fan isn't as great as it should be), and has started making a lot of noise when it spins up.

So the other day, I rang the extended warranty company and filed a claim. They gave me a claim reference, and noted that all I had to do, was to drop it off at the same company again, Highpoint, and quote the claim and it would be taken and inspected and they would get back to me if it would be covered.

Well today, leaving the organising of dropping it off to my mum, she rang them just to find out what time they were open, as to not miss them.

On calling, the number provided by Prestige, it was a number for Highpoint, but more so someone's desk phone. They were great and transferred her to the right place, where she spoke to a person who noted that in order to lodge the laptop, that a Job ID would need to be obtained, and this can be obtained via Acer Technical Support. After explaining that the Claim ID had been provided by the Extended Warranty company, and that the laptop was more than 1 year old, it wasn't covered by the manufactueres warranty, the CSR representative agreed to create a Job ID for her, but would not be covered under any warranty, instead would be charged and invoiced to her. Knowing that this is not the case, with the notes that I had left her. She rang me to ring them. After I spoke to them, no one else was none the wiser, and I suggested that with the Extended Warranty documents in hand, ring Highpoint again, and note which company had provided it, and get them to look it up, as they must have some information about that companies extended warranty account. Again, she was told that it was irrelevant, and that she should ring Prestige.

On phoning prestige again, they reiterated what had originally been told. That the Claim ID was all that was needed, and just note that it was a claim from Prestige under extended warranty.

Fed up of being tossing back and forth on the phone, she went down, with warranty, laptop and all other details to Highpoint, to find out what the matter was. The staff member on the desk, again, had no clue what this Claim ID was, and how it related to the them, and was unwilling to deal with anything. So while, at Highpoint, Prestige was called again, to note that Highpoint was refusing to accept the laptop with that Claim ID, because it had no Job No. In the end, on my mum's mobile, the Highpoint staff member spoke to Prestige, and they worked out in the end, that while the documents from Prestige were sent to the right place email address, Highpoint had no reference, because the email address in question, could not be addressed, or seen by anyone except service staff. And thus, they would not accept the laptop, because they had no indication of who would be paying for the laptop service, or where to send the invoice.

Finally thinking they had made a breakthrough, the Highpoint staff member created a Job ID, relevant to the Claim from Prestige, and started to process.

Now, I should note that before I sent the laptop off, I backed up and wiped any files that I had on there, formatted, and installed Ubuntu on the laptop. When I did so, I created a user/pass combination that I couldn't remember. I was under the full expectation that when I got the laptop back, I would be formatting and reinstalling again in any case, because I really don't trust my documents or that with anyone else.

And this is where it gets interesting. Highpoint who by now had the computer turned on to see what the problem was, and that, noted that the screen was "black" for a long time during boot, and considered that this may be a problem with the laptop (It's actually unrelated to anything, I noticed this as soon as I installed the latest Ubuntu, that it wouldn't display the fancy graphics on boot, but instead nothing - Gentoo didn't do this). But this is a fair point. It can easily be misconstrued.

It was about this time that I got a phone call from my mum again, who shocked me with the information that they are after. They wanted to know the username and password to log into the system. Now, sure, if the error was software, I could understand that they would want to log into the system. But no, it was the fan. Part of the Hardware. Part that had been replaced already once! After nothing this to her, they were still ademant they wanted the password. And as noted before, I cannot recall what password I put on the system, but the laptop will make the noise without the need. I said if they really want, format the computer and install something else - there is nothing on it that needs to be - but there is nothing wrong with the software.

The only valid reason I can see they need to get into the system, is so run some intensive application, to cause the CPU to heat and the fan to activate. But then this isn't even neccesary, as the system still gets warm, even without going much.

Finally they took the system in, to be looked at, and in their benefit, said that they may even replace the case near the hinge, as it is starting to crack (go plastic). But that was only after forms were signed that it was okay to format the HDD and that, so they dont get into shit.

For some reason I can see that they are going to charge for the format/installation of Windows or whatever crap they put on. Which will then cause me to go down and complain a bit more myself.

It's times like this, that Dell actually look good when it comes to after sales service/warranty issues.

Published: 17 October 2007 # — Tags: laptop

Acer Aspire 1694 and ACPI

So, 3 months in from purchasing my laptop, and I finally decided that i would have another shot at trying to fix ACPI problems with it. This being the fact the battery always reports dead by default, while this statement is conclusively not true (the laptop itself tells me it is full ;-)

So, to resolve this, it requires a custom [HTML_REMOVED]DSDT[HTML_REMOVED] file to be read in, and used instead of the vendor supplied one. To do this, required some gentoo patching, with the [HTML_REMOVED]DSDT initrd patch[HTML_REMOVED]. Basically this allows you to put a custom DSDT that is read on boot, from the initrd (or more so, the initramfs).

The kernel patching, and recompiling part wasn't overly hard, as the patch for my kernel applied cleanly to gentoo-sources. Recompiling to simply enable support for RAM disk and DSDT from initramfs was painless.

The hardest part in the task, was the creation of the initramfs image. While some other distributions seem to provide a [HTML_REMOVED]mkinitramfs[HTML_REMOVED] application, gentoo does not, only a [HTML_REMOVED]mkinitrd[HTML_REMOVED]. So this created some problems, with me trying to work out how to create a initramfs manually. In the end I found the solution by emerging [HTML_REMOVED]media-gfx/splashutils[HTML_REMOVED], which contains a script called [HTML_REMOVED]splash_geninitramfs[HTML_REMOVED], which gave me the answer on how to do it. For notes sake, here is how it is done.

Put all your files to be on the initramfs in a directory, for example ~/disk Then, while in directory of the files (~/disk), type the following command:

[HTML_REMOVED]find . | cpio --quiet --dereference -o -H newc | gzip -9 > ../initramfs.img[HTML_REMOVED]

From there, you will find your new initramfs image in the parent directory named [HTML_REMOVED]initramfs.img[HTML_REMOVED].

After that, just copy initramfs.img to /boot, and add to your grub.conf

[HTML_REMOVED]initrd /initramfs.img[HTML_REMOVED]

And there, now I have a working Battery meter, so i know when the battery is going to go flat in future :-)

Note: These notes were how it would be done on gentoo, some distros might have a easier way of doing it (can it get much easier tho?! ;-)

Published: 17 May 2006 # — Tags: acer, howto, laptop